Short-Term Rentals vs. Long-Term Leases in Detroit, MI
January 8, 2025
Short-Term Rentals vs. Long-Term Leases in Detroit, MI: Which Is More Profitable?
As a property owner in Detroit, MI, you have a crucial decision to make: Should you rent your property as a short-term rental (STR) like an Airbnb or opt for a traditional long-term lease? Both strategies have pros and cons, but which one maximizes ROI, cash flow, and occupancy rates in Detroit’s evolving real estate market?
In this in-depth guide, we’ll break down:
- Profit potential of short-term vs. long-term rentals in Detroit
- 2024 market trends affecting rental demand
- Legal & regulatory challenges for STRs in Michigan
- Key metrics (occupancy rates, average daily rate, maintenance costs)
- Case studies of successful Detroit landlords
By the end, you’ll know which rental strategy aligns best with your investment goals.
Detroit’s Rental Market Overview (2024)
Detroit’s real estate market has been booming, with rising demand for both long-term rentals (due to affordability) and short-term rentals (thanks to tourism and events). Key factors influencing profitability:
- Median Rent (Long-Term): ~$1,200/month (for a 1-bedroom)
- Average Airbnb Daily Rate: ~120–
- 120–180/night (depending on neighborhood)
- Occupancy Rates:
- Long-term: ~95%+ (high demand, low turnover)
- Short-term: ~60–75% (seasonal fluctuations)
- Tourism Growth: Detroit saw 19.5 million visitors in 2023 (up 8% YoY), boosting STR demand.
Verdict: Short-term rentals can yield higher nightly revenue, but long-term leases offer stability. Let’s dive deeper.
Short-Term Rentals in Detroit: High Income but High Effort
Pros of STRs in Detroit
- Higher Daily Rates – A well-located Detroit Airbnb can earn 3,000–3,000–5,000/month (vs. 1,200–1,200–1,800 for long-term).
- Flexibility – You can block off dates for personal use or renovations.
- Tourist & Event Demand – Major events (Movement Festival, Detroit Auto Show, Lions/Pistons games) spike bookings.
- Appreciation Potential – STRs in hot areas (Downtown, Midtown, Corktown) gain value faster.
Cons of STRs in Detroit
- ⚠ Regulatory Risks – Detroit has strict short-term rental laws (permits required, owner-occupancy rules in some zones).
- ⚠ Higher Expenses – Cleaning fees, furnishing costs, and dynamic pricing tools (e.g., Pricelabs) eat into profits.
- ⚠ Seasonal Demand – Winter bookings drop, while summer (festival season) peaks.
- ⚠ Management Hassle – Guest turnover, last-minute cancellations, and damage risks.
Detroit Airbnb Profitability Example
Metric for Detroit STR (2-Bed Downtown)
- Avg. Daily Rate (ADR) $150
- Occupancy Rate 65%
- Monthly Revenue 150x20nights=∗∗150x20nights=∗∗3,000**
- Expenses (30–40%) ~$1,200 (cleaning, utilities, etc.)
- Net Profit$1,800/month
- STRs work best in: Downtown, Midtown, Corktown, and near Ford’s Michigan Central innovation hub.
Long-Term Rentals in Detroit: Steady & Low-Maintenance
Pros of Long-Term Leases
- Stable Cash Flow – No vacancy worries (Detroit’s rental demand is strong)
- Lower Operating Costs – No furnishing, cleaning, or constant guest turnover
- Easier Financing – Banks prefer long-term rentals for mortgages.
- Less Regulation – No permit headaches (unlike STRs).
Cons of Long-Term Leases
- ⚠ Lower Monthly Income – Fixed rent vs. dynamic STR pricing.
- ⚠ Harder to Raise Rent – Rent control discussions in Michigan could limit increases.
- ⚠ Longer Tenant Risks – Evictions are costly if tenants stop paying.
Detroit Long-Term Rental Profitability Example
Metric for Detroit Long-Term Lease (2-Bed in New Center)
- Monthly Rent$1,500Vacancy Rate5% (1–2 weeks turnover)Expenses (20–30%)~$450 (maintenance, property tax, insurance)Net Profit$1,050/month
- Best for: Investors who want passive income with minimal management.
Which Is More Profitable? Key Considerations
Factor Short-Term Rental vs Long-Term Lease
- Monthly Income Higher (3K–3K–5K) or Lower (1K–2K)
- Occupancy Stability Seasonal (60–75%) or Consistent (95%+)
- Management Effort High (Daily Tasks) or Low (Lease & Forget)
- Regulatory Risk High (Permits) or low Low
- Best For Hands-on investors or Passive landlords
Detroit-Specific Tips
- Short-Term Rentals work near Downtown, Midtown, and Corktown (high tourist traffic).
- Long-Term Rentals thrive in family-friendly areas (Rosedale Park, University District).
- Hybrid Strategy: Some landlords do medium-term rentals (30+ days) for corporate tenants.
Final Verdict: Should You Choose STR or Long-Term in Detroit?
Choose Short-Term Rentals If…
- You’re near a high-demand tourist/event zone.
- You can handle hands-on management (or hire a co-host).
- You want higher upside (but accept volatility).
Choose Long-Term Rentals If…
- You prefer steady, low-effort income.
- Your property is in a residential (non-tourist) area.
- You’re wary of Detroit’s STR regulations.
Bonus Tip: Test Both!
Some Detroit landlords start with long-term leases, then switch to STRs during peak seasons (summer, major events).
Ready to Maximize Your Detroit Rental Income?
Whether you choose short-term or long-term rentals, the key is data-driven decisions. Need help optimizing your strategy?
- 📞 Contact Suite Properties for a FREE rental analysis!
Multifamily properties continue to be a cornerstone of wealth-building through real estate. When you combine their income stability, appreciation potential, and tax advantages, it’s clear why so many investors are drawn to them
In Detroit's dynamic rental market, thorough tenant screening remains the cornerstone of successful property management. At Suite Properties, we understand the unique characteristics of Detroit neighborhoods and rental dynamics.
If you own an investment property and you have tenants, it is inevitable that you will, at some point, have to deal with complaints from your tenants. It is best to be prepared for this eventuality so that you know what the most common tenant complaints are, and how to handle them. Dealing with tenant complaints quickly and efficiently will give you a good reputation as a landlord and keep your tenants happy so that they have no qualms about renewing their leases. This is essential if you want to maximize the returns on your property investments. Here are three of the common complaints tenants have, and how best to deal with them. 1. Pests
We've all heard horror stories about problematic tenants and absent property managers, but what does the average experience of working with a property management company offer? Like most things, a lot will depend on the company you choose to work with, but overwhelming landlords and tenants will say that working with a good property management company makes everything easier. A property manager isn't just responsible for collecting the rent every month. Many companies offer a full-service approach to provide ease and peace of mind to landlords and an excellent experience for tenants. Preparation and Tenant Screening Great property management companies are involved in every step of the renting process, from preparing the unit, to maintaining it throughout the tenancy. This starts with property marketing. Property managers know the importance of not having vacant units for an extended time. View our available properties in Detroit The advantage of a company specializing in attracting and maintaining good tenants is that they know how to attract the right people. After a suitable applicant has been found, the property management company will then handle the entire screening process. This will include background checks and the removal of high-risk applicants from consideration so that landlords are left with the most qualified leads. The management company will also handle property showings, walkthroughs, inspections, and the documentation of the property's condition during both move-ins and move-outs. They will also take care of any necessary repairs that need to be done. Maintenance & Rent Collection In Detroit, MI, an exceptional property management company will also be responsible for maintaining the property while the tenants occupy the unit. Instead of needing to contact contractors or repair people and juggle their schedules with yours and your tenants, the property manager will handle it all from start to finish. Often, excellent property management companies will have their own connections and dedicated technicians to address emergencies on-site. Learn more about our Detroit Property Management Services Rent collection is another service that is provided by property managers. They will collect the rent on time every month and will be the ones to follow up with tenants if the rent is late. In the worst-case scenario, if you have a problem tenant, the property manager will also be the one to begin the eviction process and deal with all of the legal considerations of tenancy issues. Financial Reporting & Business Streamlining Ultimately owning a rental property is a job all on its own. Working with a professional property management company means regular updates on the business’s financials and access to accounting and financial services. The ability to have all of the expenses and revenue reflected and organized through a third-party can take a lot of stress and pressure off landlords. Get in touch with Suite Properties today Further, the peace of mind offered by a Detroit property management company can not be overstated. The time saved from showing suites, running background checks, vetting references, arguing about late rent payments, or dealing with problematic tenants is often well worth a management company's cost. Besides the time saved, it can also reduce a lot of stress and headache that occurs with problematic tenants or even just the regular upheaval of move-in & move-outs and the various steps associated with preparing the unit for a new occupant.
If you want to rent out your property for extra income, but you don’t think you will be able to manage all the added work, then this article is for you.
